Protein Rant


No this is not someone trying to preach veganism on you and defend themselves about where they get their protein from, I simply want to address the misconception of the ‘protein craze’ and ‘high protein diets’ they we as a society are faced with and many are influenced by.
By no means at all am I saying to stop eating any plant-based foods and that you can’t be healthy if you do consume them, I am purely trying to provide you with information to try and make healthier changes to your like style that are going to be sustainable and work for you and benefit you. All I’m really recommending is to eat more fruit and vegetables, that’s all I really want anyone to try and do, because they truly are healing!
Now, Protein:
Research suggests that consuming over 30% of your daily caloric intake from protein can place added stress on internal organs such as the kidneys, liver, and heart. One of the biggest misconceptions is that more protein is needed for muscle growth while weight training. The only criterion for building strong muscles is proper and consistent training, as well as meeting the caloric needs for your body and activity level.  

Protein deficiencies only exist in the presence of total caloric insufficiency, meaning that in order to meet our basic protein requirements; we have to eat enough of the right food.
The diet and nutrition industry pushes protein as the most important component of the human diet, but nitrogen only makes up 3% of our total body mass (compared to oxygen which makes up 65%, and carbon at 18.5%). The recommended daily allowance (RDA) for protein according to US government standards is 46 grams for women and 56 grams for men; these figures account for roughly 7% of the total daily caloric intake (based on a 2500 calorie diet for women, and 3000 calorie diet for men). The World Health Organization suggests a protein intake of 2.5-10% of total calories. The goal is to consume no less than 50-75% of the protein requirements for your body.  

General recommendation is to get 20% or less

Ironically, the majority of our protein needs are met by internal protein sources. The human body actually recycles and reuses a considerable amount of protein (70-100 grams) per day in the form of endogenous protein (internal protein)
Exogenous, external protein sources, are concentrated in the foods that we consume on a daily basis. External protein sources can be separated into two categories: animal based sources and plant based sources. 

Animal based sources:  Meat, Poultry, Fish, Eggs, Dairy

The main issue with consuming animal-based protein sources is that they are high in protein AND fat, as well as saturated fat, cholesterol, sodiumheterocyclic amines, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (linked to cancer formation).

Example: The average 8 oz. New York strip steak contains a whopping 65 grams of protein, 450 calories, 11 grams of saturated fat, 150 mg of cholesterol, and 0 grams of fibre.

Firstly, the protein content is over the daily recommendation, the saturated fat and cholesterol levels are above 50% of the recommendation for any individual consuming daily 2500 calories but also the lack of fibre is going to make it hard to digest the steak and remove it from the body, increasing the risk of colon cancer and other gastrointestinal disease and not only that but your body is going to use up a great deal of energy trying to digest that steak that it could be using to provide you with greater energy in your everyday life.

 It is recommended to include no more than 5% of daily calories for animal-based sources in order to prevent disease and illnesses.

Also, please understand that animal based proteins are actually secondary sources of protein. Animals are required to consume their protein from plant-based sources (eg: cow eating grass).

I felt so silly when I first heard that.. it makes so much sense but we are bought up just knowing that animals contain protein but I guess we don't think about where they get theirs from!

Plant based sources:  Legumes/Beans, Grains, Nuts, Seeds, Starchy Vegetables, Green Leafy Vegetables, and Fruit
One of the major differences between plant based protein and animal based protein is fibre. Fibber is a dietary component that is responsible for the movement of food through the digestive tract as well as the removal of undigested food (including protein and fat).  Without sufficient fibre intake, the foods that we consume can remain trapped in the digestive tract for days, weeks, months, and even years. This can increase our risk of colon cancer and other gastrointestinal diseases. It is always recommended to have a side of salad or vegetables with your meal, whether it be oatmeal, stir-fry, curry, soup, fish and chips, pizza etc.

Plant- based foods are easier for the body to absorb as they require less energy to digest, therefore resulting in a greater absorbing of nutrients while at the same time a greater amount of energy.
Fruit contains the most bio-available amino acids because fruits are the easiest and quickest foods to digest (as long as the fruit is ripe). So even if you only consumed fruits and vegetables, you would still meet your protein requirements as long as you consume enough calories from the foods.

Exceeding protein requirements generally means that there will be a lack of carbohydrates coming in to the diet, which can interfere with how the metabolism functions.  If protein and fat intake exceeds carbohydrate intake, or if carbohydrate intake is not enough to support energy demands; the body will revert to burning protein/fat for fuel (gluconeogenesis).  Since any excess protein/fat are immediately stored for later use, this fat burning concept sounds great to many but the actual process of converting protein/fat into glucose is a very energy demanding and inefficient process.  
Now for the serious gross stuff..
Ketosis is the toxic condition that results from the burning of protein/fat for fuel.  Ketone bodies are the by-products of this reaction, and due to their high level of toxicity, must be removed immediately.  Typically if a person is following a high protein/fat diet
(Atkins, South beach. Paleo, Ketogenic) the kidneys filter out the ketones along with internal water stores (to dilute the toxins), which results in dehydration and (water) weight loss on the scales.  

This metabolic situation mimics starvation, and the metabolism lowers in an effort to conserve fuel.  Weight gain typically follows a ketogenic diet, as the body stores both water and food until the metabolism recovers back to normal.  In the long term, a ketogenic diet can cause blood sugar imbalances, nutrient imbalances, hypothyroidism, blood pressure, imbalance, metabolic damage, depression/anxiety, kidney/liver disease, disorders related to chronic dehydration, heart disease, cancer, gastrointestinal disorders (IBS, constipation, diverticulitis), inflammatory diseases, and premature aging.
I’m sorry if I’ve offended anyone or come across as a preacher, these are not my intentions

Lil x


-          Information sources from http://www.nutritionbyvictoria.com/blog.html

No comments:

Post a Comment